Part Two: Are We Overemphasizing Emotions?


Possible consequences of an over-emphasis on emotions:

  1. Self-pity. A nearly natural response to bad things happening to you. Why me? (Would it be better if it was someone else? “Yes, someone deserving. I don’t deserve this.” ) Self-pity, even when it is realistic, is seductive, but alas unhelpful as a coping mechanism (It is also rather unattractive to others). Taking on this identity is to take a shovel and to dig yourself in deeper.
  2. Victimhood. This is what you become if you indulge in “me” talk. When you believe yourself to be the unfortunate victim of others. Even to the extent that this might be true, I have learnt over the years that this is never entirely true after the age of 12. And the older you get, the less true it is. Best is to accept from an early age that you are the co-author of your own life story. This is good news! It is much better than the alternative.
  3. Please note that I am not saying that emotions are not important and should preferably be side-lined. The ability to recognise and to identify your emotions as well as those of others is a vital life-skill. However, this ability is the just a part of your journey towards wholeness, it is not the entire journey itself.

An anecdote

The son of a school friend, who was rather awkward and nerdish, struggled to find a date for his final year high school dance. My friend felt really sorry for her son. How dejected he must feel. His 15-year-old sister, who later became a successful occupational therapist (for a good reason as we shall see) had a better plan:

“Let us go for dancing lessons. I will go with you. And if nobody else wants to go with you to the dance, I will.”

His sister is not only inventive, she is also very good-looking.

It turned out that the young man had talent. He and his sister dressed up to the nines for the dance and captivated their peers. Ever since, he is a popular choice for dances and sought after by girls, who incline towards good rhythm anyway.


An overemphasis on Emotions

The effective intervention – the teenage sister empowering her brother through dance – does not place the emphasis on the deflating emotions.

It is certainly not necessary to always name feelings. Especially in the normal course of everyday life. Hopefully, it is clear from the anecdotes that a good solution redresses an implicit problem.  Being able to identify the underlying problem, is as important as accepting feelings.  A really good solution empowers.  If a child is not selected on a team and is upset, it is appropriate to reflect on their disappointment and possible feelings of “being left out”. If the underlying reason is insufficient skills, you have to decide: is this something that can be achieved and thus can be directly addressed, or should you find another activity that will suit your child’s aptitude better? An ice cream cone is a comfort, it is not a solution.

Having trouble making friends? Feeling side-lined and rejected? Being bullied? The advantages of search engines are that you can google why this could be so, and what you can do about it. (In later blogs I will write about grief and trauma.)

Because we tend to respond to negative feelings more often than to positive ones, this leads to an imbalance in focus, which leads to neurosis [1] (unhappiness).

An emphasis on “I” plus an emphasis on feelings, is a feature of a  “neurotic” person which may be why teenagers have such a propensity for being unhappy and why we all need outside interests to keep us sane.


A final short anecdote:

A grandchild was jealous at the arrival of a new sibling. She tells my husband, with some hint of anger, “I do not like my sister! He replies, with a hint of compassion“ Oh dear, I have bad news for you: One cannot choose your family, you just have to learn to live with them.”

I still like this reply as it neither denies nor opposes her experience. There is an implicit acceptance of her experience, but it is placed within a practical, universal frame that helps her to contain and guide her feelings.


An extract from recent research:

Depressive symptomatology is manifested in greater first-person singular pronoun use (i.e., I-talk), but when and for whom this effect is most apparent, and the extent to which it is specific to depression or part of a broader association between negative emotionality and I-talk, remains unclear. Using pooled data from 4,754 participants from 6 labs across 2 countries, we examined, in a preregistered analysis, how the depression –I-talk effect varied by (a) first-person singular pronoun type (i.e., subjective, objective, and possessive), (b) the communication context in which language was generated (i.e., personal, momentary thought, identity-related, and impersonal), and (c) gender. Overall, there was a small but reliable positive correlation between depression and I-talk (07, .13). The effect was present for all first-person singular pronouns except the possessive type, in all communication contexts except the impersonal one, and for both females and males with little evidence of gender differences. Importantly, a similar pattern of results emerged for negative emotionality….. These results suggest that the robust empirical link between depression and I-talk largely reflects a broader association between negative emotionality and I-talk. Self-referential language using first-person singular pronouns may therefore be better construed as a linguistic marker of general distress proneness or negative emotionality rather than as a specific marker of depression.

Tackman, A. M., Sbarra, D. A., Carey, A. L., Donnellan, M. B., Horn, A. B., Holtzman, N. S., Mehl, M. R. (2018). Depression, negative emotionality, and self-referential language: A multi-lab, multi-measure, and multi-language-task research synthesis. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. Advance online publication.http://dx.doi.org/10.1037/pspp0000187

[1] Neurosis, a slightly old-fashioned term, is one of the big 5 personality traits. To read about them, you can look up:

https://www.verywellmind.com/the-big-five-personality-dimensions-2795422

One response to “Part Two: Are We Overemphasizing Emotions?”

  1. […] “symptoms” of a neurotic person. As is an overuse of the word “I”.  (More about this in Part Two of this […]

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: